
Pod 51
Best for efficient, budget-conscious Midtown stays with social dining and a rooftop view.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Pod 51 is a compact, value-minded Midtown East hotel with small, efficient rooms and a lively on-site restaurant and rooftop terrace—good for travelers who want a central Midtown base without luxury prices. The Mercer is a 4.5-star SoHo boutique known for understated loft-style rooms and a quieter, design-forward neighborhood stay—best for travelers who want an upscale SoHo address and larger, loft-like rooms.
Updated · about 3.8 km apart

Best for efficient, budget-conscious Midtown stays with social dining and a rooftop view.

Best for quieter, design-forward SoHo stays and loft-like guestrooms in a boutique setting.
When Pod 51 wins: pick Pod 51 if you want a central Midtown East location close to Rockefeller Center, Grand Central and Fifth Avenue, small efficient rooms (including shared-bathroom options) and an active on-site bar/restaurant plus a rooftop terrace—all at lower rates.
When The Mercer wins: choose The Mercer if you prefer SoHo’s galleries and boutiques, larger loft-style rooms with a more luxurious finish, and a quieter neighborhood base a short walk from Washington Square Park and NYU.
Bottom line: Pod 51 is the practical, social Midtown option for travelers who prioritize location and low cost; The Mercer is the upscale boutique choice for visitors who want SoHo style and roomier, design-focused accommodations.
| Category | Pod 51 | The Mercer |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Efficient, social Midtown hotel with compact rooms and a lively bar/restaurant. | Upscale SoHo boutique with understated, loft-like rooms and quieter ambiance. |
| Location | Midtown East — close to Fifth Avenue, Rockefeller Center and Grand Central. | SoHo — steps from NYU and Washington Square Park, close to galleries and designer shops. |
| Size (rooms) | Around 348–354 rooms, including shared-bathroom pod-style options. | 73 guestrooms. |
| Age policy | Guests must be at least 18 to check in; property is all-ages overall. | Not published |
| Pools | No on-site pool; rooftop terrace is available. | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Clinton Hall (American bar/restaurant) + Pod Café; outdoor beer-garden-style courtyard and rooftop bar space. | One restaurant (Sartiano's) with bar/lounge and 24-hour room service; cooked-to-order breakfast available (surcharge). |
| Spa & wellness | No on-site spa listed; rooftop terrace for relaxation; fitness center presence unclear across sources. | Spa services and onsite massages/facials available; 24-hour fitness facilities and fitness classes advertised. |
| Known for | Pod-style compact rooms, social beer-and-burger venue, and an affordable Midtown rooftop. | Loft-like rooms, SoHo location near Washington Square Park and NYU, and a boutique luxury feel. |
| Accessibility & family services | Accessible path to elevator, wheelchair-accessible public washrooms; pets allowed (small dogs). | Wheelchair accessible with some accessible features listed; complimentary WiFi and concierge. |
| Parking & arrival | No on-site parking; nearby ICON Parking with validation; facility fee applies ($29.84/night). | Valet parking (surcharge) and covered parking available; limo/town car service offered. |
Pod 51 sits on a tree-lined block in Midtown East near Fifth Avenue and major transit.
Pick Pod 51 for convenient Midtown access to transit and major tourist sites.
The Mercer is in SoHo, within steps of NYU, Washington Square Park and SoHo’s shops and galleries.
Choose The Mercer to stay in SoHo for shopping, galleries and a quieter, neighborhood feel.
Pod 51 emphasizes compact, efficient rooms with a mix of private and shared-bathroom options.
Pod 51 is for travelers who accept very small rooms in exchange for lower prices and social spaces.
The Mercer offers larger, loft-like room types with higher-end finishes.
The Mercer suits travelers who want roomy, design-focused accommodations in SoHo.
Pod 51’s on-site food and drink keep things casual and social.
Pod 51 offers casual, budget-friendly dining and a social bar atmosphere right in the hotel.
The Mercer focuses on a single on-site restaurant with Italian cuisine and room service.
The Mercer delivers a quieter, table-service dining experience tied to a boutique hotel rhythm.
Pod 51’s main signature amenity is its furnished rooftop terrace on the 14th floor.
Pod 51’s rooftop is the go-to spot for views and social time—there’s no pool or spa on site.
The Mercer highlights on-site spa services and more traditional boutique-hotel amenities.
The Mercer offers spa and fitness options for wellness-minded guests rather than a rooftop social scene.
Pod 51 is more about social dining and rooftop hangouts than formal wellness facilities.
Expect casual nightlife at the hotel and practical accessibility features; fitness/spa options are limited or unclear.
The Mercer combines fitness and spa programming with an understated SoHo nightlife proximity.
The Mercer is better suited to guests who want on-site spa/fitness options and access to SoHo’s quieter evening scene.

Pod 51 — compact rooms, shared-bath options and lower nightly rates for price-conscious visitors.

The Mercer — loft-like suites and a boutique SoHo address for travelers who want a quieter, upscale stay.

Pod 51 — Clinton Hall, a beer garden courtyard and a furnished 14th-floor rooftop terrace.

The Mercer — SoHo location near Washington Square Park and NYU with on-site spa services.
Pod 51 — it’s in Midtown East within easy walking distance of Rockefeller Center, Fifth Avenue and Grand Central.
The Mercer — its room types (SoHo Studio, Lofts) are described as loft-like and larger compared with Pod 51’s compact pod rooms.
No. Both hotels charge separately for breakfast: Pod Café at Pod 51 and cooked-to-order breakfast at The Mercer are available for a surcharge.
Pod 51 does not have an on-site swimming pool. The Mercer’s supplier listing does not publish a pool.
Explore how Pod 51 stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·